Let’s Split Up!
The investigators return to the Fresno House. Ms. Delacroix excuses herself to take a nap. The rest split off into pairs to do some investigating around town.
Before leaving, Ada calls Dr. Miller’s home and speaks to his wife. She learns that Dr. Miller returned home but has been away for about a week to “take some time for himself,” since he hasn’t felt quite right since returning from Port Harbor. Ada passes along her best wishes and hangs up.
Ada and Martin
Ada and Martin saddle up Lincoln, Martin’s horse, and ride out to the ruins of the Luminous Church of the Ten Heartfelt Fires. The compound has been ravaged by fire and cordoned off by police, but there is no one else around. It becomes clear that the church has not been visited by anyone since shortly after the fire. Martin finds a ladder and uses it to climb up and peer down the roofless silo. Below, he sees that the altar to Hylmunder has been shattered, presumably by people wielding pickaxes.
Ada is still curious about the tunnels beneath Port Harbor, and expresses an interest in finding the presumably sealed off entrance that once led to the Underground Railroad cavern. She and Martin ride link down the banks of the Abanasset River, until they come upon what appears to be a very old rockslide.
Ada clambers over the rocks and finds a narrow gap that opens out into a void below. She decides to shimmy into the hole to see what’s on the other side, only to misjudge the sturdiness of her perch and the depth of the hole. She falls, knocking the wind out of herself on the muddy ground. Martin, horrified, runs to fetch rope from Lincoln’s saddle.
Since she’s down in the cave already, and since she happens to have a flashlight in her purse, Ada does some exploring. She finds an old, dust-covered encampment in the cavern, as well as various supplies and ancient tins of food. She also notes that a tunnel leads away from the cave and roughly toward the center of town. Near the tunnel entrance, she finds a crate that contains large candles. She also spots a number of “hobo symbols” carved into the tunnel walls.
Playing her flashlight around the cavern, Ada thinks she glimpses a shadowy figure in the distance. When she swings her light back to inspect the area more closely, the figure is gone.
Martin returns with the rope and and uses it to hoist Ada safely out of the cave.
Alfie and Dale
Alfie decides to pay a visit to Estelle LePage, his childhood acquaintance. Dale offers to come with. Alfie is otherwise fine with this but suggests that Dale put on a suit. Dale does so, wearing the one nice suit he has owned for several years. He is not comfortable wearing it and needs a few fashion tips from Alfie to get it up to snuff. Tugging at his collar, Dale follows Alfie to his car, and the two of them drive over to the LePage residence. Alfie makes a quick stop on the way to buy flowers.
The house is in a higher-class neighborhood in the north of Port Harbor (not as nice as Alfie’s own neighborhood, but close enough). The house looks significantly more run down than its neighbors, with an overgrown garden, indifferent repair work, and various signs of decay.
The two men mount the crooked steps at the front of the house and ring the doorbell. They are soon greeted, but not brought into the house, by a somewhat formidable older woman wearing a housecoat and carrying a feather duster. Alfie recognizes her as Dolores Caine, Estelle’s childhood governess.
Dolores eventually recognizes Alfie, whom she last saw as a child, and gradually warms up to him as he displays his natural charm. She tells Alfie that Estelle isn’t home and that she has “a project” that keeps her away from the house for days at a time.
Alfie asks after the family and learns that Estelle’s father died a few years ago and that the family finances have suffered badly since. He offers his condolences, and the flowers, and says that he would very much like Estelle to contact him when she comes back. He also complements Dolores, saying that he is sure that, with her discipline and guidance, Estelle has surely grown up into a fine young woman.
Dale, who has had some calling cards printed up for the Fresno house, politely hands one to Dolores. He notices that Dolores seems to be quite taken with Alfie, but also notices that she winces slightly when Alfie calls Estelle a “fine young woman.” He suspects that Dolores disagrees with this assessment of Estelle’s character.
The two men leave the LePage house. As they drive away, they wonder how recent the picture that they have of Estelle is. Alfie points out that the LePages were once society people, and probably had their pictures in the paper from time to time. Dale suggest visiting the library to look up old editions of the Port Harbor News-Reader, while Alfie decides to go right to the source.
The Port Harbor News-Reader
Alfie’s entrance into the newspaper offices shocks the receptionist and brings several reporters scurrying out of their offices. This includes Catherine Planchett, who is very excited to see Alfie. She says that she will be happy to let the two men get the information they need, provided that Alfie gives her an exclusive interview. Alfie says he is free to sit down to an interview, “any time she wants,” and immediately regrets it.
Catherine takes the two men into the archives and gives them a brief tour. She suggests that they check out the flat file cabinets, where the paper stores its stock pictures.
Dale starts going through the flat files, but accidentally pulls out one of the drawers completely out of the cabinet. There is a loud rattle and bang as pictures fly everywhere. Catherine blanches and flees the archive room, loudly trying to cover up the accident.
Her ruse does not work and Jeff Doyle, the cigar-smoking editor-in-chief of the paper comes stomping into the archival room. He demands to know what the hell the two men are doing in and to his archives. Dale panics and tries to put the drawer back, but only succeeds in misaligning it and making horrible metal on metal scraping noises. Catherine comes to the rescue by taking Dale outside, promising him a cup of coffee. “It’s terrible, but it’s free!”
Alfie explains that they’re here to get an archival picture of Estelle LePage. Doyle, probably as an excuse to get rid of the two men, helps Alfie find the picture. It turns out to be a duplicate of the one the investigators already possess. It is dated 5-11-1922 and the description, “LePage, Estelle – Great War Charity Benefit.”
Doyle has Andy, presumably one of the staff photographers, make a duplicate of the photo for Alfie to take.
A Visit to Clayton Kent
While they’re out on the town, Alfie decides to pay a visit to Clayton Kent and ask him to dinner. He and Dale visit the phone booth in front of the newspaper and get Kent’s address from the phone book. They learn that he lives in Cannot Point, and drive down there.
Kent arrives home at roughly the same time as Dale and Alfie do. He is being dropped off by a friend, is looking a little ragged around the edges, and is carrying a battered protest sign.
He greets both men warmly and, upon recognizing Alfie, thanks him for his help and hopes that he wasn’t too badly manhandled by the cops. The three mene exchange pleasantries and then Alfie invites Kent over to dinner the following evening. Alfie also mentions the possibility of supporting Kent’s campaign.
Kent enthusiastically accepts the invitation before excusing himself to go rest. Dale cannot shake the feeling that there is something very familiar about Kent.
Driving away, the two men happen to pass the Cannon Point Hotel, where they see Val and Father Wilk—who are seemingly dressed in uniforms—getting into the Fresno car.
Val and Father Wilk
Father Wilk wants to pay a visit to the Cannon Point Hotel (the largest hotel in Port Harbor), to see if anyone related to their investigations has stayed there. Val not only volunteers to come with him, but also offers to disguise them both as hotel employees.
They take the Fresno car down to the hotel. Val then quickly leaves and returns with various accoutrements that feature the hotel’s embroidered logo. She and Father Wilk sneak around to the employee entrance of the hotel and prepare for their infiltration.
Just as Val is putting the finishing touches on their disguises, the door of the employee entrance bursts open, and the hotel’s concierge comes running out. He is ecstatic and relieved to see the two investigators, demanding that they come with him at once.
As they follow him through the back hallways of the hotel, the concierge explains that a Marquis de Borgeous has just arrived, and the hotel has no record of his visit. Since the marquis is, well, a marquis, the concierge has been frantically trying to sort everything out while desperately trying to save face. He implores Father Wilk and Val to do whatever the marquis says, give him whatever he wants, and take him up to his suite on the eighth floor.
The duo are introduced to the marquis, who is a portly, well-dressed man with a horrible attitude and roughly eighty bags, cases, and trunks. Father Wilk quickly finds a bellhop cart and starts loading it up while Val dawdles for a bit and earns the marquis’ ire. The marquis loudly disparages Val’s skills and breeding, which angers Val. She tries to take revenge by pressing every floor button inside of the elevator, but accidentally traps herself inside with the marquis.
“I wasn’t sure of your floor, and I didn’t want to miss it!”
The duo accompanies the now enraged marquis to his room and follow his instructions to place his luggage on the bag. Val struggles with one especially heavy trunk but, despite her best efforts, it crashes to the floor, its lid popping open. The marquis rushes to slam the lid shut, but not before Val and Father Wilk see a engraved plate that looks like the back of a $1 bill.
Father Wilk attempts to get a tip from the marquis, only to be rebuffed in the strongest possible terms.
Room 308
Free of their entanglement with the marquis, Father Wilk and Val sneak over to the unoccupied front desk to get a look at the hotel ledgers. They are interrupted by a guest who wants to check in. Father Wilk ducks down behind the counter to hide, while Val does a passable job of assigning the guest to their room and handing over their key.
Father Wilk discovers that an M. Collins checked into Room 308 for an extended stay—from 11/1 to 11/21/1924. He and Val both agree that a search of Room 308 is in order.
Before they can get away, the desk clerk returns and is horrified to find them behind the desk. He accuses them of trying to make him look bad and steal his job, but Val placates him and insists that they’re all on the same side and the concierge is a bit of a jerk, really. The clerk seems mollified by this and lets them go.
Val and Father Wilk take the stairs to the third floor and discover that their luck has changed for the better. A maid is in the process of cleaning up Room 308 and so its door is open. The maid barely registers the duo, but this does not stop them from coming up with a cover story to explain their presence. They say that there have been complaints that 308 has been left dirty and ask the maid if she’s seen anything. The maid takes umbrage with this and says she has cleaned the rooms like she always does.
The duo says that the concierge put them up to it. The maid lets them search the room but does not like them better for it. Val finds a scrap of notebook paper with some notes written in a woman’s hand. “Fresno will reading 11/15, seven people attending.” Father Wilk finds part of a brochure that has a picture of Port Harbor Congregational Church on one side and a bunch of text in German on the other side. Father Wilk recognizes the word, “Altergarten,” but not much else.
The duo escapes the hotel and happen to see Alfie and Dale drive by as they approach their car.
Back at the House
Everyone returns to the Fresno House. Ada takes a moment to bathe, change, and paint her cuts with iodine. Then, everyone compares notes—literally in the case of Father Wilk and Ada. Ada and Martin notice indentations on the back of the note Val found, and Val sprinkles the paper with powder to see if she can reveal any words. This works, and the back of the note reads, “Meet at Memorial. Story is "union information.”
There is some discussion of which memorial the note refers to, and Dale wonders if there’s a Memorial Hospital in Port Harbor (there is not).
During this discourse, Alfie excuses himself and uses the house phone to contact Emmitt Britt, the lawyer who is running for First Selectman. He invites Britt to his home for brunch the following day, which Britt accepts. Knowing that Charlie the hot dog vendor is a big fan of Mr. Britt, Alfie excuses himself, drives to the train station, and also invites Charlie along for brunch.
The exhausted investigators puzzle over the revelations they have uncovered before taking an early dinner and going to bed. Alfie, for his part, drives home.
The Phone Call
At about three in the morning, the house phone rings. The noise wakes Father Wilk and Martin, who both arrive in the living room at roughly the same time to answer the phone. Father Wilk defers to Martin.
A whispered voice on the other end of the line identifies itself as Dan Heidecker, who is calling from the sanitarium and is looking for Dr. Miller. Dan tells Martin that he’s not crazy—well, he is crazy, but not about this—and insists that he has seen monsters roaming around the hospital.
As Martin relays this information to Father Wilk, someone on the other end shouts at Dan to get off the phone. Then the line abruptly goes dead.