This game is notable for being the first one where I allowed
my players to write up between game actions (BGAs). This is a thing that I
stole from LARPing. It allows the players to conduct their own investigations
on their own time and to make the game world feel bigger and more lived in. It
also helped me to see what they were interested in and tailor the story
accordingly.
I will henceforth be including the BGAs my players wrote in
the comments at the end of each of these little recaps, for fun and for completeness’
sake.
October 3, 1925 (Continued)
The game starts with the Silver Twilight Lodge party finally
breaking up. Everyone has their own adventures as they head on home.
Ron
Asks to be dropped off quite a ways away from his new place
(actually, Gabriella’s place), so that he can walk home and clear his head. The
party at the Lodge made him feel deeply uncomfortable and insecure, and he got
way drunker on the Lodge’s illegal liquor than he was expecting.
He reaches the house, only to encounter his Darragh MacGowan,
one of New York’s finest, is waiting for him. Darragh has a quirk where he adopts
an Irish accent (even though he was born in the States), as a way of making
others feel more at ease around him. All it does is piss Ron off.
After mocking Ron, Darragh tells him that he stopped by to
warn him that Jimmy “Big Grin” Bianco, the new head of the Bonano Family, may
be out to get him. Ron refuses to listen and starts taking swings at Darragh.
Darragh playfully swats the first two away before he starts to get mad. Unfortunately
for him, the third punch hits him square on the chin, causing a major wound and
leaving Darragh laid out in the street.
Without a backward glance, Ron goes upstairs to go to bed.
Dr. Black and Mikhail
Doctor and patient have a nightcap at Mikhail’s apartment,
where they learn more about one another and where Dr. Black resets Mikhail’s
nose.
After the doctor leaves, Mikhail reaches into the pockets of
James’ coat and finds a many-times folded piece of legal notepad paper with the
words, “VLACTOS” and “TAWIL AT UTMIR” on it.
Kane
Visits his friend (and downstairs neighbor) Horus, a voodoo
priest, and tells him about the Order of the Silver Twilight. Horus agrees to tell
Kane what he knows, but he wants a bottle of wine first.
Judge Putnam and Johnny
Johnny feels pretty proud of himself after abandoning Dr. Black
at the Lodge (he was the doctor’s ride, but he also wanted to get the hell out
of there before the assault on Mikhail’s nose led to anything worse.
They drove to the carriage house, were we learn, for the
first time, that Johnny lives in the carriage house on the judge’s property.
Johnny helps the judge get ready for bed and then goes to sleep himself.
Judge Putnam falls asleep while reading the newspaper.
Vivian
After dropping Ron off, Vivian and her father go back to the
stately Bernouse residence. Vincenzo mentions that he wants nothing else to do
with the Lodge. Vivian is just glad the day is over. They both go to bed.
October 4, 1925
It’s Sunday! Most everyone goes to church. Then the
intrigues resume.
Ron
Wakes up late, mostly ignores his new girlfriend, despite
her being very nice to him and cooking him a big breakfast.
Still bothered by last night, and by the visit from his
brother-in-law, Ron decides to call his old house to see if he can talk to Ron
Jr. about what’s going on. He is not at all pleased when ANOTHER MAN
answers the phone.
Ron, still in his shirtsleeves, drives over to the family brownstone
and forcibly introduces himself to Billy Young, his wife’s new boyfriend, who
is inexpertly trimming the hedges. An inevitable confrontation between the two
men (one of whom is holding gardening shears), is interrupted when Connie and
Ron Jr. come back from church. Connie humiliates Ron in front of the entire
neighborhood when she screams about his infidelity at the top of her lungs. Ashamed,
Ron flees the scene, but not before he tells Ron Jr. about what happened on the
previous evening with Darragh.
Dr. Black
Reads about James Clark’s disappearance in the newspaper.
Does some investigation into medical records regarding James Clark and John
Scott, but with little success. Has some tea. Helps Vivian locate Mikhail.
Judge Putnam and Johnny
The Judge also reads about Mr. Clark’s disappearance in the
newspaper. Johnny remembers the “kerfuffle” in front of the Auxiliary building
and links the two events. Shortly thereafter, the Judge gets a hand-delivered
letter from Mr. Scott, asking him to join the Order of Silver Twilight. The duo
then decides to head down to the police station for some target practice.
Vivian
Gets a call from Deborah, who is with Angie. Angie is sober
enough to remember what she did and wants to apologize to Mikhail. Vivian does
some phone sleuthing, tracks down Mikhail, and arranges for him and the three
ladies to meet at a public café. Mikhail, who looks a little worse for wear,
decides to go, hoping that Angie is now alert enough to answer his questions.
![]() |
| Deb Walsh |
Kane
Also receives a hand-delivered letter from Mr. Scott to join
the Order of Silver Twilight (waiving the usual membership fee). The letter is
very much backhandedly complimentary. Kane acquires wine and visits Horus, who
explains that the Order, for whatever reason, doesn’t much differentiate
between foreigners/people of color from their WASPy members, which is unique in
these sorts of groups. He also explains that the Order may be related to the
Knights of Silver Twilight, a Teutonic order similar to the Knights Templar,
who were known to traffic with demons and the occult.
Vivian and Mikhail
The meeting and apology session goes adequately. It is at
this point we learn that the reason Ange’s purse broke Mikhail’s nose is
because it’s where Ange stores her fully loaded .45 automatic.
Mikhail suspects that Deborah is up to something, and offers
to walk Angie home (an apartment house nearby) to get her alone and get more
information. He does so, with middling success. He confirms his suspicions:
James had been ditching Angie for unspecified reasons before disappearing
completely. He later learns that Deborah and Vivian followed him at a safe
distance. Deborah leaves to go check on Angie. Vivian decides that she wants to
get some more answers from Mikhail, and so invites him back to stately Bernouse
Manor.
Judge Putnam and Johnny
Johnny demonstrates that he has lost none of his wartime weapon proficiency at the rage, while Judge Putnam fails to hit anything and also jams his gun. The judge questions the duty sergeant about James Clark’s disappearance, and asks to be kept in the loop regarding the case. Johnny convinces the judge that he needs to use the restroom, then bribes the duty sergeant to get some additional details about the case.
Vivian, Mikhail, and Ron
Ron shows up at the Bernouse place, dressed up, but
unshaven. He invites himself to a meeting between Vivian and Mikhail, in which
the details of James Clark’s disappearance, and Mikhail’s relationship to them,
are discussed. Mikhail shows off the paper that he found in James’ coat. The
trio suspect that some of the words might be Persian or Arabic, and decide to
head to the library to do some research.
Judge Putnam and Johnny
Realizing that various games are afoot, the Judge has Johnny
hand-deliver a letter (explaining his intentions to, and conditions for,
joining the Order) to the Lodge. Johnny goes to the Lodge and finds it
seemingly empty. Uncomfortable with dropping off the letter, he waits for an
hour in the car. An hour later, Carl Stanford arrives on the scene. The two
have a pleasant chat, during which Johnny is encouraged to join the Order. Johnny
drops off the letter and leaves. Meanwhile, Judge Putnam calls Dr. Black and
arranges for “the group” to meet at his house tomorrow, Monday, October
6th.
Vivian, Mikhail, and Ron
At the library, they learn a few things. Thanks to Ron’s
keen eye and his ability to read, they learn that symbol of the Order is tied
to numerous occult groups and “New England witches.” Vivian reads up on the
Knights of Argent Twilight, an excommunicated order of crusader knights known
for blasphemy and demon worship. They find nothing on the word “VLACTOS,” but
“TAWIL AT UTMIR” is similar to a reference on “’Umr At-Tawil,” an Arabic word
inscribed on the gate of a lost city in the Sahara Desert. The phrase roughly
translates to, “The Most Ancient and Prolonged of Life.”
Mikhail happens to discover a book on New York witches,
which contains a newspaper clipping that discusses the death of one Johannes
Scott, accused necromancer and warlock, at the hands of an angry mob in 1721.
The group soon learns that Scott’s house was located in Rananchqua, the old
Native American name for the region that now encompasses the Bronx. Mikhail is
all set to do more investigating, but Vivian, badly spooked by what they have
discovered, excuses herself and swiftly exits the library.
![]() |
| The article Mikhail found |










